TrollEye Security

Cybersecurity

Using Protection Level Agreements (PLAs) to Secure Executive Buy-In

Security leaders often lack a clear way to define what 'secure enough' means to the business. This article explains how Protection Level Agreements can give executives a framework, similar to

A Practical Framework for Communicating with Business Executives

Security leaders are under constant pressure to balance risk, budget, and business velocity, often without a clear framework to define what “secure enough” really means. While Service Level Agreements (SLAs) are common in IT and vendor management, cybersecurity still lacks a standardized way to formalize internal protection expectations and risk tolerance.

That’s where Protection Level Agreements (PLAs) come in.

PLAs give CISOs and security leaders a structured way to communicate with business stakeholders through a fact-based conversation, one that clearly defines acceptable risk, expected protections, and the resources required. By documenting which threats are actively defended against, which risks are accepted, and where the organization sets its security baseline, PLAs transform vague goals into a measurable, enforceable strategy.

In this article, we’ll break down what a PLA should include and how to build one, so you can drive clarity, align stakeholders, and gain executive buy-in.

What Are Protection Level Agreements?

Protection Level Agreements (PLAs) are internal security contracts that define the level of protection an organization commits to for specific assets, systems, or business functions. Unlike SLAs, which focus on availability or performance, PLAs focus on security outcomes, what risks are mitigated, what controls are in place, and what threats the organization is actively defending against.

A well-structured PLA includes:

  • Asset or system scope – What the agreement covers (e.g., a cloud environment, a business-critical application, or a department’s endpoints).
  • Threat model – The types of threats the organization expects to defend against, based on likelihood and impact.
  • Control commitments – The specific protections in place (e.g., MFA) and protections that need to be added (e.g., EDR, encryption, continuous testing).
  • Resources committed – The staffing, budget, tools, and services allocated to achieve the agreed-upon protection level.
  • Residual risk – What risks are accepted, transferred, or outside the scope of the agreement.
  • Review and update cadence – How often the PLA will be re-evaluated based on new threats, business changes, or incident learnings.

In short, PLAs allow security leaders to say, “Here’s what we’re protecting, how we’re protecting it, and what we’re not protecting against”, and to do so with business leadership’s buy-in.

How Protection Level Agreements Can Be Applied

Protection Level Agreements are most powerful when used to navigate the gray areas where security, cost, and business risk intersect. They don’t eliminate risk, they clarify it. By defining exactly what is being protected, how it’s protected, and what level of investment is required, PLAs help ensure everyone understands the trade-offs involved.

Whether launching a new product, migrating critical systems, or enabling remote work, a PLA turns abstract security goals into concrete decisions. It provides a structured way to say: “This is the level of protection we’re committing to. This is what it will cost. And this is the risk we’re accepting by not going further.”

Scenario 1: Driving Executive Buy-In to Close Critical Security Gaps

Context: A major financial services firm is preparing to launch a high-value B2B transaction platform. While an initial security budget has been allocated, a mid-project review by the CISO’s office reveals that only 52% of critical systems are fully patched and hardened against known vulnerabilities. The remaining systems are exposed to high-impact threats, including credential compromise, lateral movement, and API abuse, threats well-documented in the firm’s threat model and validated through red team simulations.

Challenge: The current budget and staffing levels are insufficient to close the remaining security gaps before launch. The CISO must secure an additional $500,000 in funding to fully implement patching, hardening, and threat detection across the remaining systems. Without this investment, the organization risks non-compliance with PCI DSS and SOX and is exposed to preventable attack paths.

PLA Use: To move the conversation from abstract risk to actionable decisions, the CISO drafts a Protection Level Agreement (PLA) in collaboration with the CFO and COO. The PLA outlines:

  • Scope: The remaining 48% of critical systems requiring remediation before the platform goes live.
  • Objectives: Achieve 100% patching of critical systems, implement endpoint detection and response across the environment, and close identified privilege escalation vectors.
  • Threat Model: Credential theft, API-based lateral movement, and exploitation of unpatched third-party services.
  • Accepted Risk: If the $500,000 is not approved, the organization acknowledges that nearly half of its most sensitive systems will remain vulnerable to known exploits and that security incidents could lead to regulatory fines, service disruption, or reputational harm.
  • Budget Request: $500,000 in additional investment, covering contractor support, patch automation, and expanded detection coverage.
  • Review Cadence: Biweekly reporting to executive stakeholders; formal PLA review every quarter or post-incident.

Outcome: By clearly quantifying both the investment and the residual risk of inaction, the PLA reframes the conversation. Instead of debating theoretical threats, leadership makes a decision based on cost-benefit and risk trade-offs. In this case, the additional funding is approved, and the CISO receives executive support to fast-track remediation. The PLA serves as a shared accountability mechanism that ties spending to protection outcomes and clarifies what remains at risk if priorities shift.

Scenario 2: Rationalizing Legacy System Protection in a Global Manufacturing Enterprise

Context: A multinational manufacturing company is undergoing digital transformation, migrating key operations to the cloud while still relying on decades-old legacy systems for production and logistics. These on-premise systems are difficult to patch, have limited vendor support, and are critical to daily operations. The CIO plans to minimize investment in these systems, citing upcoming cloud transitions and budget limitations.

Challenge: The CISO’s team identifies multiple high-severity vulnerabilities within the legacy environment, including outdated operating systems and exposed management interfaces. While the cloud migration roadmap is underway, it’s estimated to take 18–24 months. During that time, threat actors could exploit these weaknesses to disrupt manufacturing processes, leading to costly downtime or safety risks.

PLA Use: To clarify what’s at stake and move beyond vague security concerns, the CISO develops a PLA with IT, operations, and finance leadership. The document includes:

  • Scope: All legacy systems supporting production and logistics at five global sites.
  • Objectives: Implement network segmentation, intrusion detection, and compensating controls to reduce the blast radius of potential attacks during the transition.
  • Threat Model: Ransomware, remote access trojans, and supply chain compromise targeting unpatched systems.
  • Accepted Risk: The PLA acknowledges that full hardening of these systems is not financially feasible and that certain vulnerabilities will remain exposed. Business units accept the risk of extended downtime (up to 72 hours) in the event of compromise.
  • Budget Alignment: $300,000 approved for segmentation and endpoint monitoring; full migration funding to remain separate.
  • Review Cadence: Monthly review with site-level IT and security leaders, with incident triggers prompting a reassessment.

Outcome: The PLA enables informed decision-making across departments and avoids finger-pointing when risk materializes. It documents the temporary nature of risk acceptance and ensures business units take shared responsibility for legacy exposure during the migration window.

Scenario 3: Prioritizing Security Efforts in a Fast-Growth SaaS Startup

Context: A venture-backed SaaS company is rapidly scaling to meet customer demand, with product, engineering, and sales teams pushing new features weekly. Security has been addressed in an ad hoc manner, with minimal tooling and no centralized oversight. The company just landed a major enterprise customer who requires SOC 2 Type II compliance within six months.

Challenge: The Head of Security identifies several gaps that need immediate attention: missing audit logs, weak access controls, and lack of defined incident response processes. To meet SOC 2 requirements, the company will need to invest in security automation, documentation, and staff training, but product and engineering teams are already stretched thin, and leadership is hesitant to divert resources.

PLA Use: To break the stalemate, the Head of Security drafts a PLA between security, engineering, and executive leadership. It defines what the company must protect, what’s required to meet compliance, and what will happen if they fall short.

  • Scope: Security controls, documentation, and response processes required for SOC 2 compliance across the platform and cloud infrastructure.
  • Objectives: Pass a SOC 2 Type II audit within six months; implement SSO, MFA, audit logging, and vendor due diligence within 90 days.
  • Threat Model: Insider threats, unauthorized access, insecure third-party integrations.
  • Accepted Risk: Without investment and cooperation, the company may fail the audit, resulting in delayed enterprise contracts and reputational damage. These risks are explicitly documented and signed off by department heads.
  • Budget Alignment: $200,000 allocated for tooling, external audit preparation, and security headcount.
  • Review Cadence: Weekly cross-functional meetings during the compliance sprint, with a 60-day reassessment post-audit.

Outcome: The PLA creates transparency, aligns the startup’s rapid growth with customer trust requirements, and holds teams accountable for their role in meeting compliance. When friction arises, the agreement serves as a reference point to keep efforts focused and justified.

Rather than asking for budget without context, or accepting risk without clarity, PLAs provide a way to say: “Here’s what this level of investment will protect, and here’s what it won’t.” That transparency empowers business leaders to make informed decisions and gives security teams the support they need to operate with focus and purpose.

Six Steps to Building a Protection Level Agreement (PLA)

Building a PLA requires collaboration between security teams and business leadership. It’s not just a technical document, it’s a strategic agreement that defines how your organization allocates protection, accepts risk, and communicates priorities. Below are six key steps to guide the process:

These steps ensure the PLA is not just a static document, but a living agreement that evolves with your organization. By building your PLA thoughtfully, you create a strong foundation for strategic security decisions and executive alignment.

Use PLAs to Communicate in the Language of Business Leaders and Secure Security Investment

Assumptions don’t get budgets approved, business cases do. Protection Level Agreements give security leaders a way to speak the language of business by clearly connecting investment to protection outcomes. They turn vague discussions about risk into concrete decisions backed by data, priorities, and available resources.

By outlining what will be protected, what risks will remain, and what it will take to achieve those outcomes, PLAs make it easier to secure executive buy-in. They create transparency, increase accountability, and help ensure that security investments are aligned with business goals.

If you want business leaders to fund protection, give them a framework they can act on. PLAs make that possible.

Share:

Live Product Update

Meet the Future of
Risk & Remediation

Introducing two major additions to the TrollEye CTEM platform, designed to help teams move from exposure to action.

AI Remediation Agent

AI assistance to help security teams move from findings to fixes faster.

Business Risk Dashboard

New visibility into breach probability, financial risk, and compliance.

Hosted By

Avery Rozar Avery Rozar CEO, TrollEye Security
Sullivan Tuck Sullivan Tuck Head of Growth & Marketing
December 17, 2026 • 2:00 PM ET • Live Online
Reserve Your Spot →

This Content Is Gated